2020-10-14 Leadership Cadence
Date
14 Oct 2020
Participants
Emily Crose
Goals
Discuss FOIA and board membership logistics
Discussion topics
Topic
Presenter
Notes
FOIA
Primer questions:
What do we do with FOIA?
How do we want to approach Stonewalling
What can we even do to compel valid responses from FOIA requests?
Is there a way to source the information around which agencies fulfill/evade requests
What are the gaps that we need information for that FOIA can fulfill?
What does our attitude need to look like when we interface with the other end of these FOIA requests?
FOIA is an activist endeavor - how far as a group should we take that at this moment in time?
Comparing federal agencies vs non-federal FOIA requests
Federal agencies
Generally consistent regarding the kind of information that we get
State and local
Complete dismissal/non response for requests
Invalid excuses on not being able to fulfill requests
I.e. “non-existing” documentation for involvement/support of OPERATION LEGEND will require the generation of new documents to fulfill the request; law enforcement doesn’t “have to comply” because they cite that FOIA only applies to already existing documents
Paywalled behind large pre-processing fees
Requests for what should be readily available information (such as mission statements) are rejected in FOIA requests
There’s value in the process of making FOIA requests, in addition to the content
They hold law enforcement accountable
Response/non-response can be tabulated as a data point
Metropolitan police departments have not been reliable in fulfilling requests
We can cross reference FOIA sourced data points with NIBRS/state-IBRS data points for inconsistencies
Current state of PDAP support for FOIA
For FOIA requests to take, there’s a need for legal representation that PDAP currently doesn’t have
It’s been mentioned that we can seek this legal representation out if it’s not A&P
We’ll have more pull once we’re incorporated and not simply a group
Volunteer data opportunity - get someone to make requests and keep count of who fulfills/evades requests
Identify what the expectations are for a request
Document actual experience and how it differs from expectations
Direction
Current issues with Muckrock preventing us from socializing the FOIA requests to the rest of the group
May require some follow up with Muckrock
As we flesh out the NIBRS/OIBRS comparisons, we’ll have more information on what is missing and what we could potentially have FOIA fill in
Board
We’ll generally want folks that will be active participants and consistently around
How do we make sure we stay diverse, and what does that look like for us?
Leadership to DM Eddie for those interested
Full Name
Address
Splunk
Alec taking the lead on interfacing with reps from Splunk
Action items
Zach GoulsonWill Beaumont Send Eddie a DM about board positions. Full name and address
Making a FOIA request that is in line with what the FBI requests of local jurisdictions